Practicing CSA cases with colleagues is one of the main forms of preparation for the CSA exam. This exercise can be efficient, beneficial and lead to exponential growth in confidence…OR…it can end up hammering in bad habits, being done ‘for the sake of it’ and generally being a waste of valuable ST3 time.
These 5 thoughts are developed from personal experience of having prepared for the CSA myself, as well as from seeing 1000’s of trainees prepare for the CSA over the last 6-7 years.
1) Record your CSA case practice.
Recording and play-back can be an extremely valuable growth tool – but consider extending this to recording your cases in CSA study groups.
Lets face it – our mindset is often different to real life when we are preparing for CSA (anxiety, stress etc), and you want to see what you do in THAT mind space….What mannerisms do you display?
Which words do you use? How clearly do you explain things? Which cues do you miss? It is so important that you recognise your good and not-so-good points in your ‘CSA zone’ – often remarkably different to those when consulting in real life…. Alongside recording your real-life consultations, there is often no better way to do this that recording and watching your own cases back after a study group session.
So often we base how successful study group sessions are solely on how many cases we get through. Of course number of cases are important but it is vital to get as much as you can from each case. Self-reflection of performance AFTER the session, for example on the drive home, is where the magic really happens. Rather than switching off, go back through each case that you did yourself and break it down in your mind. You may have thought it went well at the time and would probably have forgotten it completely, but become a little self-critical. Did I actually ask all the red flags that I should have? Did I know what the guy did at work or find out if his symptoms affected it? Did I come back to the alcohol like I said I was going to? Did I really involve him in the second half, or did I take over for 3 minutes?…Only through this detailed process of self-critique, when you are on your own and not under pressure to move straight onto the next case, will you realise where YOUR improvement points are…Without doing this you may make the same omissions and errors next time too.
3) Practice back-to-back.
At our courses I’m often amazed when it is the first time that someone has done more than one case back-to-back. We ensure that you get this experience, as it is vital to see how you cope when cases go wrong…. A really common scenario that I often hear about after a CSA exam: “the first case was so difficult and I completely messed it up – the rest of the exam was affected by that”. This only happens if you haven’t practiced how to move on from a case that went horribly wrong. Please take some time to string some cases together when you practice – it is only through practice that you can figure out how to move on from a case that you know went terribly…Advice is often given to ‘just forget the last case and move to the next’ – actually having the skill to do this in reality takes practice…again and again and again…
4) Be challenging when acting.
I remember practicing with friends – everything was nicey-nicey. ‘Actors’ were all friendly, sometimes information was given too easily and feedback was always based mainly on the medicine. ‘Should you have given this drug or that?’, ‘was that referral based on the current guidelines? etc. Of course these are all very relevant but two things were usually lacking….Firstly I had not experienced the other challenges that the exam can test such as emotion, communication difficulty etc, and secondly there was not enough appreciation or discussion on areas other than ‘clinical’, such as whether the ICE was addressed or whether practical suggestions for the patient’s work issues were explored…So when you practice with friends or colleagues, 1) aim to challenge each other in areas other than making the medicine difficult and 2) make sure you discuss the other vital aspects of the CSA afterwards.
5) If attending a course, go early rather than late.
Attending a course is not necessary for everyone and many pass the CSA without attending a course. However if you do attend a course, book on early if you can. When people attend our course often they leave saying they wish that they’d attended earlier – we cover a huge amount of challenging and raw material on the day (30 cases in 1 day ensures hundreds of learning points) and most people need time to process, reflect and practice what they have picked up. There are also many who deliberately choose to come nearer to the exam however (we do get many attend in their final week!) but ideally I’d suggest 2-5 months beforehand if you had an open choice….The other thing I’d suggest is that if you do attend a course, consider attending with your study-partner or group (most courses have a discount for group booking). Practicing in a group after a course can be so much more beneficial if those practicing are on the same wavelength as you!
– Record your own cases in study groups.
– Critically reflect on your cases after the session.
– Get used to the pressure of back-to-back cases.
– Challenge each other when being the actor.
– If you attend a course consider attending earlier rather than later and if possible, with study group members.
How we can help you pass CSA
There are many ways that we can help for CSA – focused on multiple different leaning styles. Many choose to use one, some use several – we recognise that everyone’s needs are completely different. Below are some examples of what we offer, with a full overview here.
1) Our Flagship Immersion CSA Course. 30 intense role-plays over a 12-hour day, designed to expose you to those challenging scenarios that many struggle with, including medical complexity, communication challenge, ethics, shared-decision making etc. Small numbers to ensure highly personalised feedback. Held every month in London, Birmingham and Manchester. Ideally attending 2-5 months before your exam produces maximum benefit. Full details of coverage here.
2) Our CSA-125 Online Course. 125 CSA-type scenarios broken down in an intense 6+ hour online training course. I break down the most common presentations, situations and scenarios in terms of data gathering, interpersonal and management. Includes key red flags, up-to-date guidelines, relevant psychosocial links as well as options for shared management. Watch-back, pause and rewind as many times as you like throughout a 1, 3, 6 or 12 month subscription option. For a free sample video click here.
3) Our CSA On-the-Go Audiobook Course. 5 hours of pure audio teaching, breaking down 100 core CSA-tyoe scenarios, focusing on all 3 key elements – data gathering, interpersonal and clinical management – including all key red flags and guidelines. Designed to download to your phone or tablet, to listen to online or offline, with no expiry. Increase your efficiency whilst listening and preparing whilst commuting or out and about. All future updated versions come free. Listen to a free sample here.
4) Our Medical ‘How to Explain’ Audiobook Course. 220+ medical conditions, diagnoses, tests and treatments explained in there most simple terms, ideal to use in your CSA exam. Improve the quality of your scenarios by breaking down your explanations into patient-friendly language. Also designed to download to your phone or tablet, to listen to online or offline, with no expiry. Increase your efficiency whilst listening and preparing whilst commuting or out and about. All future updated versions come free. Listen to a free sample here.
5) Our Online CSA Case Bank for study group practice. Designed to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of your role-plays in study groups. Designed for use with medical colleagues as well as non-medics as well. Use through your phone, tablet or laptop, wherever you are – no need for books or folders. Separate tabs for the ‘doctor’, ‘patient’ and key discussion/learning. For a demo of what it is like click here.
6) Our 60-Day CSA Revision Poster. A countdown to get you through all key areas before your CSA. Short sharp summaries of key presentations for quick glance leaning. A1 size, full colour, posted to your home or work within 2 working days. For examples see here.
7) #aroraDaily emails – our free daily evening revision emails including a quick clinical scenario and a short video teaching tutorial – designed to make preparation more efficient and ticking over everyday: http://eepurl.com/duAwXr
8) Free CSA teaching on Social Media. We have 400+ CSA teaching videos on our YouTube channel, carry out lots of teaching via our main GP Training Facebook Support group and I also teach daily through image on Instagram (@dr_aman_arora) and on Twitter (@aman999arora).
On a Final Note…
Practicing for CSA is important – firstly to do so and secondly to do in a way that actually helps improve efficiency and use of 10 minutes.
Of course you will practice heavily for your CSA when seeing patients at work – inevitably a huge part of your preparation. Everyone will develop their own practice styles, both at work and when in a study group, but bear these in mind when you next try some cases with colleagues.
Study group practice is for most a vital part of getting ready for the big day – make sure each minute of this practice counts.
Look forward to meeting you soon and good luck!